Bright open-plan kitchen and dining area in a modest new home, with off-white cabinets, warm wood-look floors and a late-autumn suburban view.

Where Columbus's New Homes Are Being Built, and What They Cost

  • November 19, 2026

Along Stella Rock Trace in Sutter Place, on County Road 200 West south of Lowell Road, the newest houses in Columbus sit in small clusters around shared motor courts. Each house covers most of its lot. The smallest plan there is the Coach, a two-bedroom home of about 1,159 square feet. Arbor Homes lists it at $199,995 as of mid-November 2026, and the builder advertises the series as starting "from the $190's."

That price is roughly $80,000 under the Bartholomew County median sale price of $282,200 for October 2026, as reported by the Indiana Association of REALTORS. It also says a lot about how new construction in Columbus works right now. If you want a brand-new house in town this winter, you will mostly be choosing among one builder's communities in one part of town. The projects approved for the west and east sides will be priced higher and arrive over the next several years, and the largest of them has shrunk since it was first proposed.

The entry-level new home is a different kind of house

Arbor Homes calls its smallest product the Arrival Series, a name that replaced the earlier Genesis label, according to The Republic. It is a two- or three-story house on a compact lot. In November 2025 the first Arrival homes at Sutter Place ranged from $199,995 to $256,995 depending on the floor plan, at 1,158 to just over 2,000 square feet. Sutter Place is planned for 92 of these homes out of 273 lots. That same month the city approved the final plat for the second section, which opened 103 lots to building permits and sales after the first 50. City planning director Jeff Bergman told the paper the subdivision would likely be built in three or four phases, depending on how fast lots sell.

For a first-time buyer, this is the price point that matters. A new Arrival home costs less than the county median, but it gives up yard space and ground-floor living to get there. An older ranch at the same price on an in-town street makes the opposite trade, with more yard and one-level living in exchange for an older house.

One builder, one corridor

Arbor's Arbor Series homes on larger lots start "from the $240's" at Sutter Place, Abbey Commons and Abbey Place. In November 2026, the one quick-move-in home Arbor showed with a published price was 4272 Sedgewick Court in Abbey Commons, a three-bedroom Chestnut plan of 1,814 square feet listed at $305,995. Abbey Place has 313 lots, and Abbey Commons sits just north of it with a little more than 40 lots.

The fourth Arbor community is Timberland Springs, on the northeast corner of Deaver Road and County Road 150 West near Walesboro. In September 2026 the Columbus Plan Commission approved a preliminary plat there for 285 lots and seven common areas on 107 acres, The Republic reported. It splits the same way Sutter Place does. Of the lots, 151 are 3,500 square feet and meant for Arrival homes in the $200,000 range, and 134 are 7,320 square feet and meant for Arbor Series homes at $300,000 to $350,000.

Timberland Springs borders existing single-family neighborhoods: Country Wood Farms and Brookside Estates to the west and Bethel Village to the east. The Walesboro airfield property sits to the south. City officials have pointed to the site's closeness to Cummins and Toyota Material Handling in Walesboro. When the project first came before the Plan Commission in February, Arbor estimated a buildout of four to five years.

Taken together, that is more than 900 planned lots across four subdivisions from one builder, all on the north side or the northeast edge near Walesboro. For a buyer, this means comparing new homes in Columbus today often comes down to choosing among floor plans and lot sizes from the same company.

The west and east side projects are further out and priced higher

Chase Point is the west side's large project. It sits on the north side of State Road 46 between County Road 500 West and Belmont Drive, about half a mile north of the site of Bartholomew Consolidated School Corporation's new Maple Grove elementary. When the City Council finalized the annexation in July 2025, developer Chase Point Capital described about 250 single-family homes plus about 130 townhomes.

By May 2026 the plan had changed. Chase Point representatives said about 20 acres of the 107-acre site has soil that is unsuitable for building near the Wolf Creek floodway. The townhomes were dropped from the plan, and the subdivision was described as about 180 homes. Jack Laskey told the council it could end up closer to 160 because of the site's terrain, The Republic reported. Jack and Tom Laskey said most homes would be around $350,000, in a cluster layout with significant open space, built in three phases with completion estimated for the first quarter of 2031.

On the east side, The Republic reported that the City Council in September 2026 finalized the annexation and rezoning of about 80 acres on the north side of Sawin Drive, about 1,300 feet west of Talley Road. The developer, Abundant Home Solutions, plans owner-occupied twin patio homes for buyers 55 and older plus some single-family homes, with a target range of $300,000 to $450,000. The developer told The Republic that construction could be one to two years away, with a five-year buildout, so most of these homes, like most of Chase Point's, will reach the market well after this winter and above today's county median.

Where the county median sits in all this

In October 2026, Bartholomew County had 99 closed residential sales, down 2% from October 2025. The median home went under contract in 25 days, and the county had 2.9 months of inventory, according to the Indiana Association of REALTORS monthly report. That is still a market where well-priced homes move quickly.

Line up the new-construction prices against that $282,200 median and they fall into two groups. Arrival Series homes at Sutter Place and the future small lots at Timberland Springs are well below the median. Nearly everything else is at or above it: Timberland's larger lots at $300,000 to $350,000, Chase Point around $350,000, and Sawin Drive from $300,000 to $450,000. Arbor Series homes starting in the $240s are the main new option between those two groups, and they are all in north-side Arbor communities.

The city has a reason to want more homes. Its 2024 housing study, the first in more than a decade, estimated Columbus needs about 300 new units a year through 2035, compared with an average of about 260 a year over the previous ten years, The Republic reported in February. Much of what that update listed as coming online is rental housing: Thrive Alliance's 64-unit Haw Creek Meadows, the 110-unit Flats on 14th, a 120-unit mixed-use building at 11th and Washington streets, and 52 market-rate units along Washington Street in front of the Cummins parking garage.

A handful of new houses are also going up on established streets through the city's PACT program, which local builders use for single-family infill homes under $300,000. Two were finished in 2025 and eight more were approved for funding as of the February update. Those are scattered lots, not a new neighborhood.

What this means for a move this winter

If you are buying and want something new under $300,000, the choice is on the north side right now. It comes down to the Arrival Series and Arbor Series homes in Sutter Place, Abbey Place and Abbey Commons, with Timberland Springs to follow. If you were waiting for the west-side subdivision near Maple Grove, the developer's own timeline runs to early 2031, and the project is now smaller than first described. Resale homes around the median in established neighborhoods remain the main way to get a full-size yard at that price in other parts of town.

If you are selling a home near the county median, your new-construction competition is concentrated in one north-side corridor, and much of it is a different product: motor-court homes on small lots, or larger plans that start in the mid-$200s and go up from there. Sellers in neighborhoods away from that corridor are mostly competing with other resale homes, not with model homes. The 25 median days on market in October 2026 shows how fast that resale competition is moving.

If you're weighing a new build on County Road 200 West against an older home closer to downtown, or wondering how your house compares with what Arbor is pricing nearby, The Nolting Team can put your address side by side with current resale data and the new-home price sheets. Start with a home value estimate, and one of our agents will follow up with the local comparisons behind it.

Work With Us

We pride ourselves in providing personalized solutions that bring our clients closer to their dream properties and enhance their long-term wealth. Contact Columbus Indiana Real Estate Agents, The Nolting Team today!

Follow Us on Instagram